• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Old Poland Bakery in Brooklyn, NY: Authentic Polish Bakery Delights

Old Poland Bakery in Brooklyn is a hidden gem with a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. Known for their peach cheesecake, babka, bread, strudels, and poppy seed rolls, this classic old Polish bakery offers high-quality baked goods at great prices. Customers rave about the moist and delectable cakes, with one saying they wish they had bought more slices to bring home. The bakery also offers savory options like apple turnovers and cheese-filled puffs. Despite a $5 card minimum, patrons appreciate the value and taste of the treats at Old Poland Bakery. Drive the extra miles for a taste of perfection.

Old Poland Bakery at a glance

  • Address 926 Manhattan Ave Brooklyn, NY 11222
  • Restaurant type Bakery .

Photos & Gallery

Old Poland Bakery: Reviews & Ratings

Alexey Chernyuk
5

Great little bakery in Greenpoint that will beat most of the neighborhood places by price and quality. I've been buying bread here for over five years to make sandwiches for my family. Croissants are bigger than usual, but that works well with my smoked salmon breakfast sandwich. My son loves the chicken sandwich I make with their harvest grain. Coming from a Russian background, you can find all the bread that is common in Eastern Europe. A staff member told me that they bake their bread at night at the pizza place nearby, which is a very charming small business story.

Sébastien Vanhoutte
5

Great place. Has been there for ever price are really good food is amazing. A place I would like to visit more often. The Makowiec is reminding me of my childhood in Europe.

Julia H
4

I got two things here, a butter bun and half bread-pudding-like triangle dessert (according to the staff.) The butter bun is big, soft and buttery enough. I made my fried fish burger with it. The dessert I got has a slice of cake as the base, then layers of soggy puffs, cream and berry jam in it which is mushy and has no texture. Overall 4 stars after considering the price!

PhilYouIn
4

Very tiny bakery in Greenpoint. Has been around for many years. We make a 45 minute drive a couple of times a year, and it’s worth it. Old time neighborhood with, gratefully, old time service. Woman working was very pleasant and patient. The pastries are very good. And the place smells nice.

Shiyu C
5

The staff was super friendly. The cheesecake was great!! It wasn’t sweet, and it was super smooth and spongy. A pastry or cake that’s not sweet is the highest compliment from an Asian person. I’m glad I walked by and tried it out!

Patty Deutsch
5

What a sweet place. I purchased potato and cheese pierogies, which were delicious and very reasonable. The varieties of polish foods and bakery items make this a go to when visiting Brooklyn. I will go back when next in the area.

Rowena
5

Been here twice and the staff is so kind every time. Delicious poppy cake and most recently discovered this loaf cake that's a mix of marble/poppy with a cherry filling in the center. So good. I wish it were closer to me but at least it's right off the G train station.

Samantha Piwniczuk
5

Their Sourdough bread and babkas are phenomenal. Staff is friendly and attentive. Worth the trip and every penny!

Location

  • Old Poland Bakery
    Old Poland Bakery
    926 Manhattan Ave Brooklyn, NY 11222

Nested between the bustling streets of Brooklyn, New York, lies a hidden gem known as Old Poland Bakery. This quaint bakery offers a wide array of delectable treats that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. With options for delivery, takeout, and the convenience of street and bike parking, Old Poland Bakery makes indulging in their treats a breeze.

Customers rave about the attentiveness of the staff, with one reviewer mentioning how they received recommendations on the bakery's favorites. From peach cheesecake to babka, each item on the menu is crafted with care and attention to detail. The classic Polish bakery specializes in bread, strudels, and poppy seed rolls that transport you to the heart of Eastern Europe with every bite.

One customer even goes as far as to say they drive 45 minutes just to get their hands on the bakery's goodies, a true testament to the quality and taste of Old Poland Bakery's offerings. With affordable prices and a welcoming atmosphere, this bakery is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in traditional Polish baked goods.

As a food reviewer, I have personally sampled the delights of Old Poland Bakery and can attest to the mouth-watering flavors and moist textures present in their baked goods. The Apple turnover and cheese-filled puff were standout items that left me craving more. The bakery's commitment to quality and taste shines through in every bite, making it a top contender for the best bakery in Brooklyn.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards